Wrongful Auto Repossession Lawyer, Texas & Alabama
Was Your Vehicle Wrongfully Repossessed?
Did they take a car you did not owe money on? Wrong car, wrong VIN, a previous owner’s lien, or a car you bought at a tow yard or police auction: that is a different and often stronger case. See car repossessed by mistake or on someone else’s lien.
Was my car repossession wrongful?
In general, falling behind on a car loan doesn’t give a lender a free hand. Both the repossession and what happens afterward are governed mainly by state law, in Texas and Alabama, Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code (for example, Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 9.609 and Ala. Code § 7-9A-609). A lender generally can’t “breach the peace” when taking the vehicle, usually must give proper notice before selling it, and has to handle the sale and any remaining balance correctly. Whether a particular repossession was wrongful depends on the facts and the exceptions that apply, so every situation should be reviewed by an attorney.
When a repossession may be wrongful
Common examples include:
- Breach of the peace: the agent used force or threats, entered a closed garage, or took the car over your objection
- No proper notice: you weren’t given the notice the law generally requires before the sale
- Improper sale: the vehicle wasn’t sold in a commercially reasonable way, inflating the balance claimed
- Wrong amount or not in default: they repossessed after you cured the default or miscalculated what you owed
- Personal property: belongings left inside weren’t returned
- Wrong car or no lien: the repo company took the wrong vehicle, or repossessed a car you had already paid off that has a clean title
This is a general list, not every scenario, and the rules differ by state and circumstance.
What should I do?
Generally, keep your loan agreement, payment records, notices, and any letters about the sale or balance, and write down how the car was taken. Don’t ignore collection letters or a lawsuit over a deficiency; those carry deadlines. Then have a lawyer review the details.
How John C. Hubbard, LLC helps
John C. Hubbard, LLC helps consumers across Texas and Alabama look into wrongful repossessions, challenge improper deficiency balances, and pursue damages where a lender or repo company broke the rules. The case review is free.
Reviewed by John C. Hubbard, Attorney, admitted in Alabama (2008) and Texas (2018), John C. Hubbard, LLC. Last updated June 2026.
Can a repossession company be sued under federal law?
Sometimes. Repossession agents are usually not treated as debt collectors under most of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, but one provision reaches them. Section 1692f(6) of the FDCPA, 15 U.S.C. § 1692f(6), prohibits taking or threatening to take nonjudicial action to seize property when there is no present right to possession of the collateral. Because a claim under that section arises under federal law, it can give a wrongful-repossession case a path into federal court, alongside your state-law claims. Whether it applies depends on the facts of your repossession.
Trial experience
John has tried wrongful-repossession and other consumer cases to verdict in Alabama state courts and in arbitration, and has obtained a federal jury verdict in a wrongful auto-repossession case. Every case is different, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Every situation is different, the rules have exceptions, and deadlines vary, so nothing here is a promise about your case. Reading this or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice on your specific situation, have it reviewed by a licensed attorney.
Written by John C. Hubbard, attorney admitted in Alabama (2008) and Texas (2018).
Was the repo also reported wrong on your credit?
After a repossession, the tradeline on your credit report is often wrong too: an inflated deficiency balance, re-aged dates, or the same debt reported twice. That can be a second, often stronger, case under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Read what to do when the repossession on your credit report is wrong.
Results in repossession cases
John C. Hubbard has obtained six-figure settlements in wrongful repossession and FDCPA cases for clients in Dallas County, Texas, and five-figure jury verdicts in repossession cases in Jefferson County, Alabama, and five-figure settlements in repossession and FDCPA cases for clients in Dallas and Houston, Texas. Every case is different; these results do not predict or guarantee a similar outcome. See more on the attorney profile.
In Texas? Start with our Houston wrongful repossession lawyer page, which covers Texas repossession law, repo injuries, and where these cases get filed.
Did an accident or injury cost you the income that led to the repossession? See car repossessed after an accident took your income.
The two questions that decide a repossession case
Was the taking itself lawful, and was the sale afterward handled correctly? Both states follow UCC Article 9, so the rules are nearly identical. A secured lender may take the car without going to court only if it can do so without a breach of the peace (Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 9.609; Ala. Code § 7-9A-609). After the taking, it must send you reasonable written notice before the sale (§ 9.611 / § 7-9A-611), including the date of a public sale or the date after which a private sale will occur, and it must sell the car in a commercially reasonable manner (§ 9.610 / § 7-9A-610). A lender that skips a step owes you damages, and in a consumer transaction it may lose the right to collect any deficiency at all (§ 9.625 and § 9.626; Ala. Code § 7-9A-625 and § 7-9A-626).
What counts as a breach of the peace
Texas and Alabama courts agree on the core: a repossession agent who proceeds over your clear, contemporaneous objection has breached the peace, and so has one who opens a closed garage, cuts a lock, or brings a police officer along to pressure you without a court order. Entering an open driveway at night, or taking the car from a parking lot while you are inside the store, generally is not a breach. The line is drawn at confrontation and at entry into enclosed space. If you told the agent to stop and the agent took the car anyway, say that in the intake, with the date and who was present. That single fact changes the case. A 2026 federal district court decision applying Georgia law, Hart v. Hill & Associates of Georgia (N.D. Ga. 2026), held that continuing to tow after the debtor and her husband objected out loud was a breach of the peace as a matter of law, and that a repossession company whose principal business is repossession is a debt collector under § 1692f(6). The objection of a spouse or another qualifying person at the scene counts.
The deficiency balance is where most of the money is
After a repo the lender sells the car, credits the proceeds, and bills you for the rest. That number is wrong more often than people expect. The lender may have sold the car at a dealer auction without the notice the statute requires, added repossession and storage fees the contract does not allow, or kept charging interest after the sale. A lender that fails to comply with Article 9 is liable for the loss its failure caused (Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 9.625(b); Ala. Code § 7-9A-625(b)), and in a consumer goods transaction the debtor can also recover a statutory minimum equal to the finance charge plus 10 percent of the principal, whether or not any loss is proven (§ 9.625(c)(2); § 7-9A-625(c)(2)). On the deficiency itself, Article 9 leaves the consumer rule to the courts: § 9.626(b) and § 7-9A-626(b) limit the deficiency rules in subsection (a) to non-consumer transactions and say courts “may continue to apply established approaches” in consumer cases. In practice, a defective notice or sale puts the lender’s entire deficiency claim in play, and the lender who sues on it, or reports it to the credit bureaus, has handed you a counterclaim.
Repossession and your credit report
A wrongful repossession rarely stays a single problem. The lender reports the account as a repossession with a deficiency balance, the deficiency gets sold to a debt buyer, and the debt buyer calls. Each step is governed by a different statute: the FCRA for the reporting, the FDCPA for the debt buyer, and in Texas, the Texas Debt Collection Act for the original lender. John C. Hubbard handles all three together, which matters because the repossession case is strongest when the lender’s own records show the sale was mishandled and the credit reporting repeats that mistake. See the firm’s guides on repossessions reported wrong on your credit report and deficiency balances reported in error.
Where these cases are filed and how long you have
Article 9 claims are state law, so they are filed in Alabama circuit court or Texas district or county court unless a federal claim under the FDCPA or FCRA is joined, in which case the whole case can go to federal court. The firm handles both. The limitations period for a wrongful repossession claim is two years in Texas for conversion and four years on the contract, and six years in Alabama for both, but the FDCPA claim against a repo agent (15 U.S.C. § 1692f(6)) is one year, so an early call is worth making.
What to send with your intake
The retail installment contract, your payment history or bank statements showing what you paid, every notice you received before and after the sale, and a short written account of how the car was taken: where it was, who was present, what was said. If you still have personal property in the car, say so; the lender must let you retrieve it. The case review is free, and there is no attorney’s fee unless money is recovered. Se habla español.
Start your case here
Tell the firm what happened below and John will review it, usually the same business day. Or call 205-378-8121 (Alabama) or 832-410-8121 (Texas).
